List of criteria | Points | Remarks |
| Criteria 1: Site Selection | 1 | Partly mandatory |
| Criteria 2: Preserve and protect landscape during construction /compensatory depository forestation. | 5 | Partly mandatory |
| Criteria 3: Soil conservation (post construction) | 4 | |
| Criteria 4: Design to include existing site features | 2 | Mandatory |
| Criteria 5: Reduce hard paving on site | 2 | Partly mandatory |
| Criteria 6: Enhance outdoor lighting system efficiency | 3 | |
| Criteria 7: Plan utilities efficiently and optimize on site circulation efficiency | 3 | |
| Criteria 8: Provide, at least, minimum level of sanitation/safety facilities for construction workers | 2 | Mandatory |
| Criteria 9: Reduce air pollution during construction | 2 | Mandatory |
| Criteria 10: Reduce landscape water requirement | 3 | |
| Criteria 11: Reduce building water use | 2 | |
| Criteria 12: Efficient water use during construction | 1 | |
| Criteria 13: Optimize building design to reduce conventional energy demand | 6 | Mandatory |
| Criteria 14: Optimize energy performance of building within specified comfort | 12 | |
| Criteria 15: Utilization of flyash in building structure | 6 | |
| Criteria 16: Reduce volume, weight and time of construction by adopting efficient technology (e.g. pre-cast systems, ready-mix concrete, etc.) | 4 | |
| Criteria 17: Use low-energy material in interiors | 4 | |
| Criteria 18: Renewable energy utilization | 5 | |
| Criteria 19: Renewable energy based hot-water system | 3 | |
| Criteria 20: Waste water treatment | 2 | |
| Criteria 21: Water recycle and reuse (including rainwater) | 5 | |
| Criteria 22: Reduction in waste during construction | 2 | |
| Criteria 23: Efficient waste segregation | 2 | |
| Criteria 24: Storage and disposal of waste | 2 | |
| Criteria 25: Resource recovery from waste | 2 | |
| Criteria 26: Use of low - VOC paints/ adhesives/ sealants. | 4 | |
| Criteria 27: Minimize ozone depleting substances | 3 | Mandatory |
| Criteria 28: Ensure water quality | 2 | Mandatory |
| Criteria 29: Acceptable outdoor and indoor noise levels | 2 | |
| Criteria 30: Tobacco and smoke control | 1 | |
| Criteria 31: Universal Accessibility | 1 | |
| Criteria 32: Energy audit and validation | Mandatory | |
| Criteria 33: Operations and maintenance protocol for electrical and mechanical equipment | 2 | Mandatory |
| Total score | 100 | |
| Criteria 34: Innovation (Beyond 100) | 4 | |
| Total score | 104 |
Tuesday, January 27, 2009
Evaluation procedure of criterion of GRIHA, an Indian rating system
GRIHA objective and its criteria
Green building rating will evaluate the environmental performance of a building holistically over its entire life cycle, thereby providing a definitive standard for what constitutes a ‘green building’. The rating system , based on accepted energy and environmental principles, will seek to strike a balance between the established practices and emerging concepts, both national and international. The guidelines/criteria appraisal may be revised every three years to take into account the latest scientific developments during this period.
On a broader scale, this system, along with the activities and processes that lead up to it, will benefit the community at large with the improvement in the environment by reducing GHG (greenhouse gas) emissions, improving energy security, and reducing the stress on natural resources.
Some of the benefits of a green design to a building owner, user, and the society as a whole are as follows: Reduced energy consumption without sacrificing the comfort levels
Reduced destruction of natural areas, habitats, and biodiversity, and reduced soil loss from erosion etc.
Reduced air and water pollution (with direct health benefits)
Reduced water consumption
Limited waste generation due to recycling and reuse
Reduced pollution loads
Increased user productivity
Enhanced image and marketability
Currently the system has been developed to help ‘design and evaluate’ new buildings (buildings that are still at the inception stages). A building is assessed based on its predicted performance over its entire life cycle – inception through operation. The stages of the life cycle that have been identified for evaluation are the pre-construction, building design and construction, and building operation and maintenance stages. The issues that get addressed in these stages are as follows. Pre-construction stage (intra- and inter-site issues)
Building planning and construction stages (issues of resource conservation and reduction in resource demand, resource utilization efficiency, resource recovery and reuse, and provisions for occupant health and well being). The prime resources that are considered in this section are land, water, energy, air, and green cover.
Building operation and maintenance stage (issues of operation and maintenance of building systems and processes, monitoring and recording of consumption, and occupant health and well being, and also issues that affect the global and local environment).
The criteria have been categorized as follows.
Site Selection and Site planning
Conservation and efficient utilization of resource
Objective – To maximize the conservation and utilisation of resources (land, water, natural habitat, avi fauna, and energy) conservation and enhance efficiency of the systems and operations.
Criterion 1 Site Selection
Criterion 2 Preserve and protect the landscape during construction/compensatory depository forestation.
Commitment Proper timing of construction, preserve top soil and existing vegetation, staging and spill prevention and erosion and sedimentation control. Replant, on-site, trees in the ratio 1:3 to those removed during construction.
Criterion 3 Soil conservation (till post-construction).
Commitment Proper top soil laying and stabilization of the soil and maintenance of adequate fertility of the soil to support vegetative growth.
Criterion 4 Design to include existing site features.
Commitment Minimize the disruption of natural ecosystem and design to harness maximum benefits of the prevailing micro-climate.
Criterion 5 Reduce hard paving on-site and /or provide shaded hard - paved surfaces.
Commitment Minimize storm water run-off from site by reducing hard paving on- site.
Criterion 6 Enhance outdoor lighting system efficiency.
Commitment Meet minimum allowable luminous efficacy (as per lamp type) and make progressive use of a renewable energy- based lighting system.
Criterion 7 Plan utilities efficiently and optimize on-site circulation efficiency
Commitment Minimize road and pedestrian walkway length by appropriate planning and provide aggregate corridors for utility lines.
Health and well being
Objective –To protect the health of construction workers and prevent pollution.
Criterion 8 Provide at least, the minimum level of sanitation/safety facilities for construction workers.
Commitment Ensure cleanliness of workplace with regard to the disposal of waste and effluent, provide clean drinking water and latrines and urinals as per applicable standard.
Criterion 9 Reduce air pollution during construction.
Commitment Ensure proper screening, covering stockpiles, covering bricks and loads of dusty materials, wheel-washing facility, and water spraying.
Building planning and construction stage
Conservation and efficient utilization of resources
Objective – To maximize resource (water, energy, and materials) conservation and enhance efficiency of the system and operations.
Water
Criterion 10 Reduce landscape water requirement.
Commitment Landscape using native species and reduce lawn areas while enhancing the irrigation efficiency, reduction in water requirement for landscaping purposes.
Criterion 11 Reduce building water use.
Commitment Reduce building water use by applying low-flow fixtures, etc.
Criterion 12 Efficient water use during construction.
Commitment Use materials such as pre-mixed concrete for preventing loss during mixing. Use recycled treated water and control the waste of curing water.
Energy: end use
Criterion 13 Optimize building design to reduce the conventional energy demand.
Commitment Plan appropriately to reflect climate responsiveness, adopt an adequate comfort range, less air-conditioned areas, daylighting, avoid over-design of the lighting and air-conditioning systems.
Criterion 14 Optimize the energy performance of the building within specified comfort limits.
Commitment Ensure that energy consumption in building under a specified category is 10%–40% less than that benchmarked through a simulation exercise.
Energy: embodied and construction
Criterion 15 Utilization of fly ash in the building structure.
Commitment Use of fly ash for RCC (reinforced cement concrete) structures with in-fill walls and load bearing structures, mortar, and binders.
Criterion 16 Reduce volume, weight, and time of construction by adopting an efficient technology (e.g. pre-cast systems, ready-mix concrete, etc.).
Commitment Replace a part of the energy-intensive materials with less energy-intensive materials and/or utilize regionally available materials, which use low-energy/energy-efficient technologies.
Criterion 17 Use low-energy material in the interiors.
Commitment Minimum 70% in each of the three categories of interiors (internal partitions, panelling/false ceiling/interior wood finishes/ in-built furniture door/window frames, flooring) from low-energy materials/finishes to minimize the usage of wood.
Energy: renewable
Criterion 18 Renewable energy utilization.
Commitment Meet energy requirements for a minimum of 10% of the internal lighting load (for general lighting) or its equivalent from renewable energy sources (solar, wind, biomass, fuel cells, etc). Energy requirements will be calculated based on realistic assumptions which will be subject to verification during appraisal.
Criterion 19 Renewable energy - based hot- water system.
Commitment Meet 70% or more of the annual energy required for heating water through renewable energy based water-heating systems.
Recycle, recharge, and reuse of water
Objective– To promote the recycle and reuse of water.
Criterion 20 Wastewater treatment
Commitment Provide necessary treatment of water for achieving the desired concentration of effluents.
Criterion 21 Water recycle and reuse (including rainwater).
Commitment Provide wastewater treatment on-site for achieving prescribed concentration, rainwater harvesting, reuse of treated waste water and rainwater for meeting the building’s water and irrigation demand.
Waste management
Objective –To minimize waste generation, streamline waste segregation, storage, and disposal, and promote resource recovery from waste.
Criterion 22 Reduction in waste during construction.
Commitment Ensure maximum resource recovery and safe disposal of wastes generated during construction and reduce the burden on landfill.
Criterion 23 Efficient waste segregation.
Commitment Use different coloured bins for collecting different categories of waste from the building.
Criterion 24 Storage and disposal of waste.
Commitment Allocate separate space for the collected waste before transferring it to the recycling/disposal stations.
Criterion 25 Resource recovery from waste.
Commitment Employ resource recovery systems for biodegradable waste as per the Solid Waste Management and handling Rules, 2000 of the MoEF. Make arrangements for recycling of waste through local dealers.
Health and well-being
Objective –To ensure healthy indoor air quality, water quality, and noise levels, and reduce the global warming potential.
Criterion 26 Use of low-VOC (volatile organic compounds) paints/ adhesives / sealants.
Commitment Use only low VOC paints in the interior of the building. Use water –based rather than solvent based sealants and adhesives.
Criterion 27 Minimize ozone – depleting substances
Commitment Employ 100% zero ODP (ozone depletion potential) insulation; HCFC (hydrochlorofluorocarbon)/ and CFC (chlorofluorocarbon) free HVAC and refrigeration equipments and/Halon-free fire suppression and fire extinguishing systems.
Criterion 28 Ensure water quality.
Commitment Ensure groundwater and municipal water meet the water quality norms as prescribed in the Indian Standards for various applications (Indian Standards for drinking [IS 10500-1991], irrigation applications [IS 11624-1986]. In case the water quality cannot be ensured, provide necessary treatment of raw water for achieving the desired concentration for various applications.
Criterion 29 Acceptable outdoor and indoor noise levels.
Commitment Ensure outdoor noise level conforms to the Central Pollution Control Board–Environmental Standards–Noise (ambient standards) and indoor noise level conforms to the National Building Code of India, 2005, Bureau of Indian Standards, Part 8–Building Services; Section 4–Acoustics, sound insulation, and noise control.
Criterion 30 Tobacco and smoke control.
Commitment Zero exposure to tobacco smoke for non-smokers and exclusive ventilation for smoking rooms.
Criterion 31 Provide the minimum level of accessibility for persons with disabilities.
Commitment To ensure accessibility and usability of the building and its facilities by employees, visitors, and clients with disabilities.
Building operation and maintenance
Objective – Validate and maintain ‘green’ performance levels/adopt and propagate green practices and concepts.
Criterion 32 Energy audit and validation.
Commitment Energy audit report to be prepared by approved auditors of the Bureau of Energy Efficiency, Government of India.
Criterion 33 Building operation and maintenance .
Commitment Validate and maintain 'green' performance levels/adopt and propogate green practices and concepts. Ensure the inclusion of a specific clause in the contract document for the commissioning of all electrical and mechanical systems to be maintained by the owner, supplier, or operator. Provide a core facility/service management group, if applicable, which will be responsible for the operation and maintenance of the building and the electrical and mechanical systems after the commissioning. Owner/builder/occupants/service or facility management group to prepare a fully documented operations and maintenance manual, CD, multimedia or an information brochure listing the best practices/do’s and don’ts/maintenance requirements for the building and the electrical and mechanical systems along with the names and addresses of the manufacturers/suppliers of the respective system.
Criterion 34 Innovation points.
Commitment Four innovvation points are available under the rating system for adopting criteria which enhance the green intent of a project, and the applicant can apply for the bonus points. Some of the probable points, not restricted to the ones enumerated below, could be
1. Alternative transportation
2. Environmental education
3. Company policy on green supply chain
4. Lifecycle cost analysis
5. Enhanced accessibility for physically/mentally challenged.
6. Any other criteria proposed by the client
Scoring points for TERI–GRIHA
TERI–GRIHA is a guiding and performance-oriented system where points are earned for meeting the design and performance intent of the criteria. Each criterion has a number of points assigned to it. It means that a project intending to meet the criterion would qualify for the points. Compliances, as specified in the relevant criterion, have to be submitted in the prescribed format. While the intent of some of the criteria is self-validating in nature, there are others for example : energy consumption, thermal and visual comfort, noise control criteria, and indoor pollution levels which need to be validated on-site through performance monitoring. The points related to these criteria (specified under the relevant sections) are awarded provisionally while certifying and are converted to firm points through monitoring, validation, and documents/photographs to support the award of point.
TERI-GRIHA has a 100 point system consisting of some core points, which are mandatory to be met while the rest are optional points, which can be earned by complying with the commitment of the criterion for which the point is allocated. Different levels of certification (one star to five star) are awarded based on the number of points earned. The minimum points required for certification is 50. Buildings scoring 50 to 60 points, 61 to 70 points, 71 to 80 points, and 81 to 90 points will get one star, ‘two stars’, ‘three stars’ and ‘four stasr’ respectively. A building scoring 91 to 100 points will get the maximum rating viz. five stars.
| Points scored | Rating |
| 50–60 | One star |
| 61-70 | Two star |
| 71-80 | Three star |
| 81-90 | Four star |
| 91-100 | Five star |
Sources :
http://www.teriin.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=77&Itemid=32